Many hydronic systems today are variable flow. Two-way control valves close down as the load drops, and the pumps slow to match. That saves pumping energy, but it changes the conditions the coil has to work in. A coil selected as if the flow were always at design can disappoint in a system where it rarely is.
What happens at low flow
When the flow through a coil drops, the water velocity inside the tubes drops with it. At low velocity the flow can become laminar, and heat transfer from the water to the tube wall falls. The coil may deliver less than expected for the flow it is getting.
At the same time, a coil that is oversized for the load can reach the required output with only a fraction of the design flow. That is normal and desirable in a variable flow system, but it means the coil spends most of its life away from the point it was selected at.
Design for the whole range, not only the peak
When selecting a coil for a variable flow system, look at more than the design point. Ask what the flow will be at the loads the building sees most often. Check the tube velocity at those conditions. Consider circuiting that keeps velocity reasonable across the range rather than only at the peak.
Designing the system for a larger water temperature difference reduces the flow required and can reduce pumping energy. It also asks more of the coil, so the coil needs to be selected for those temperatures and not for a standard one.
The control valve matters
A coil and its control valve work as a pair. A valve that is too large gives poor control at partial load, with most of the movement happening near closed. A valve that is sized well gives a steady response and lets the coil deliver its capacity across the range. Selecting the coil without thinking about the valve leaves performance on the table.
Freeze protection at low flow
Low flow also matters in winter. A coil exposed to cold outdoor air with little water moving through it is more likely to freeze than one with strong flow. Consider the minimum flow that will be maintained, how the system handles very cold weather, and whether glycol or other protection is part of the design.
Troubleshooting a coil that does not deliver at partial load
Check the entering and leaving water temperatures against the selection at the actual flow. Check that the control valve is moving through its range and not sticking. Check for air trapped in the coil. Confirm that the water temperature difference matches what the system was designed for. And confirm that the coil is piped for counterflow.
What to send us
When you request a replacement or new coil for a variable flow system, send the design flow and temperatures, the expected range of flow, the control valve type and size, and the airflow. The more we know about how the coil will actually run, the better the selection.
For venting a replacement boiler, GP Energy Products covers that in today’s article. Visit gpenergyproducts.com for more. For pump maintenance before peak load, Merion Pump Company covers seals and bearings in today’s article. Visit merionpump.com for more. For a look at how a heat transfer skid gets built, FabPro Systems covers that in today’s article. Visit fabprosystems.com for more.
HX Coils fabricates custom replacement coils. Send us the details of your system and we will take a look.
References
1. ASHRAE Madison Chapter. Advanced Coil Selection: laminar flow at low flow, tube velocity, circuiting, and minimum flow. ashraemadison.org/images/meeting/111218/advanced_coil_selection_ashrae_v2.pdf
2. Kele. Selecting Valves for Variable Flow Hydronic Systems: valve authority, rangeability, and control at low flow. assets.kele.com/content/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/selecting-valves-for-variable-flow-hydronic-systems.pdf
3. Kele. Selecting Valves and Piping Coils: coil valve sizing and the behavior of heat transfer with changing coil flow. assets.kele.com/content/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/selecting-valves-and-piping-coils.pdf